CAR Top 10% Producer
Chicago Association of Realtors
Jameson Quarterly Best
2023, 2024 & 2025
Crain's Chicago Business
As Seen In
Chicago Real Producers
Featured Agent Profile
For homeowners, investors, and developers who want more than a broker — they want strategy.
Understand timing, pricing, market depth, and your real alternatives before you list.
→Go beyond automated estimates with positioning, buyer psychology, and current market behavior.
→Review rent, expenses, upside, condition — and whether to hold, sell, renovate, or reposition.
→Separate value-creating improvements from unnecessary spend before you commit capital.
→Understand the asset, the numbers, and the goal.
Price, package, and present correctly.
Market and negotiate with precision.
Sell, hold, lease, or reposition.
Multi-unit deconversion in one of Chicago's most competitive urban submarkets. Won against every major brokerage. Closed off-market in two weeks.
$9.5M
Boutique developer sellout positioned around design, scarcity, and premium neighborhood pricing.
Record PPSF
Four 3-flats moved quickly — including one neighborhood record-breaking transaction.
2 Weeks
Choose the path that fits your situation. The goal is not to push a transaction. The goal is to understand the property, the market, and the best move.
"Three generations of Chicago developers. One operating principle: people first."
"Always put people first. Real estate isn't about closing deals — it's about building lives and accomplishing dreams."
With over 14 years of experience and a background rooted in hospitality, Matthew Neistat brings an honest, one-on-one approach to every client relationship. From first-time buyers to seasoned investors, his dedication and attention to detail ensure you're guided every step of the way.
About Matthew →Multi-unit deconversion — one of the largest in the neighborhood · CoStar News
Featured in Crain's Chicago Business
Represented Seller — Bayview LTD
4-unit investment property
Lincoln Park condo
Represented Developer — 4-Condo Sellout
Highest price per sq ft in the neighborhood
"Matt worked with me to market and sell all the properties faster than I expected. He did a great job solving problems and staying focused on getting the buildings sold. I would recommend Matt for this type of transaction all day long."
"He did such a good job that we ended up having him sell a few more — every single one sold at, near, or above the price we were seeking. It was refreshing to have such a hands-on broker — that is certainly not the norm."
"Matt knows real estate. The review can start and end there. He was able to blend the lines between honesty, transparency, and friendliness. He knows how to negotiate, what the market dictates, and does his work with a great deal of integrity."
"Matt has always been a terrific resource and truly a partner to me. He does much of the upfront legwork, is very responsive, is always on my side and looking out for me. I would absolutely refer him with very, very high marks."
"Matt sold four 3-flats in Tri-Taylor for me in two weeks. One broke a sales record. Matt's numbers are true-to-market and realistic. He took his time to get to the right price. I definitely would work with Matt again."
"My home buying experience was seamless, which I can credit to Matt's professionalism, honesty, and integrity. Even after the offer was accepted he remained extremely communicative and responsive during the closing process."
Whether you're buying, selling, investing, or simply curious about the market — reach out. No pressure, no scripts. Just an honest conversation.