Home About Search Properties Neighborhoods Mortgage Calculator Buyer Closing Costs Seller Closing Costs Vendors Contact
About Matthew Neistat

People First.
Always.

The Legacy

Real estate isn't what Matthew Neistat chose. It's what he was born into.

Growing up in Buffalo Grove, Matthew spent weekends walking job sites with his grandfather and uncle — both developers who built everything from single-family homes to high-rises across Chicago. His grandfather's rule: "Always put people first." His father and uncle: "Emphasize reputation above all else."

His father went further — a CFO who left security to build houses himself. Matthew visited those homes as a kid. That leap of faith stayed with him.

Matthew Neistat
The Broker

After Le Cordon Bleu and nearly a decade in hospitality, Matthew entered real estate in 2012. When a competitor heard he'd won the $9.5M West Loop listing — beating every major brokerage in the city and closing it off-market in two weeks — they said: "I didn't think Matt actually had the listing."

He did. Fourteen years later he hasn't regretted the leap for a second.

$0
Total Sales Volume
0%
Sale-to-List Price
0
Avg. Days on Market
0
Experience
As Seen In
CoStar News
"Won the listing against every major brokerage in Chicago. Closed it off-market in two weeks."
Read →
Crain's Chicago Business
"Off-market North Shore sale closes 10% over asking."
Read →
Chicago Agent Magazine — Who's Who 2022
"Named among Chicago's most notable agents."
Read →
Chicago Real Producers
"Inspiring the Next Generation to Take a Leap of Faith."
Read →
CAR Top 10% Producer
Chicago Association of Realtors
Jameson Quarterly Best
2023, 2024 & 2025
Chicago Agent Magazine
Who's Who 2022
Chicago Real Producers
Featured Agent Profile

Client Words

NA
Nicole Alfred-Napper
COO, Plan Companies

"He did such a good job that we ended up having him sell a few more — every single one sold at, near, or above the price we were seeking. It was refreshing to have such a hands-on broker."

KW
Kevin Werner
Co-Founder & CEO, Renovo Financial

"Matt worked with me to market and sell all the properties faster than I expected. He did a great job solving problems and staying focused on getting the buildings sold. I would recommend Matt all day long."

LS
Linda Schafer
Private Investor

"Matt sold four 3-flats in Tri-Taylor for me in two weeks. One broke a sales record. His numbers are true-to-market and realistic. I definitely would work with Matt again."

CP
Christopher Paquette
Chief Transformation Officer, Personify Health

"Matt has always been a terrific resource and truly a partner. He does the upfront legwork, is very responsive, and always looking out for me. I would absolutely refer him with very, very high marks."

KT
Kevin Tansey
First-Time Buyer, North Center

"My home buying experience was seamless, which I can credit to Matt's professionalism, honesty, and integrity. Even after the offer was accepted he remained extremely communicative."

NG
Nick & Marina Golemis
Bought & Sold, Chicago/Glenview

"Matt knows real estate. The review can start and end there. He blended honesty, transparency, and friendliness, and does his work with a great deal of integrity."

"I wouldn't be where I am without the support of my wife and the love of my son. They're my heart."

Let's start a conversation.

Begin the Conversation